| Total All-Americans | 1370 |
| First-Team All-Americans | 845 |
| Women's Skiing | 304 |
| Men's Skiing | 303 |
| Women's Track & Field | 179 |
| Men's Track & Field | 164 |
| Football | 159 |
| Men's Cross Country | 114 |
| Women's Cross Country | 68 |
| Men's Golf | 26 |
| Wrestling | 17 |
| Women's Basketball | 15 |
| Men's Basketball | 14 |
| Volleyball | 13 |
| Women's Lacrosse | 6 |
| Soccer | 6 |
| Women's Golf | 6 |
| Women's Tennis | 3 |
| Baseball | 2 |
| Men's Tennis | 1 |
| Men's Gymnastics | 1 |
| Men's Track & Field |